07/31/2026
One of the biggest broker verdicts in trucking history landed last Thursday. A Dallas jury hit C.H. Robinson for $604 million in a negligent hiring case, arguing the broker should have vetted the carrier more carefully before assigning the load.
That verdict is going to change every broker’s carrier onboarding process, because now the paperwork you thought was annoying just became the broker’s legal shield. Expect more requests for CSA breakdowns, more insurance verifications, more callbacks on inspection history.
For owner operators with a clean record, this is not bad news. Your safety score just became worth more at the negotiating table. For new authorities or carriers with hot violations, the wall got taller.
Two things to do this week. One, pull your own CSA scores at ai.fmcsa.dot.gov and see what a broker sees. Two, if a violation on your record is wrong, file the DataQs challenge. It is free and most carriers never bother.